1996 (Date Unknown) - First Reading
Susan Egan (Evelyn Nesbit), Victor Garber (Father) Joel Grey (Tateh), Audra McDonald (Sarah), Brian Stokes Mitchell (Coalhouse Walker, Jr.), Donna Murphy (Mother)
December 1996 (Exact Date Unknown) - Second Reading
Brian Stokes Mitchell (Coalhouse Walker, Jr.), Ann Crumb (Mother), Peter Friedman (Tateh), Thursday Farrar (Sarah), Tovah Feldshuh (Emma Goldman), Stephen Bogardus (Father), Steven Sutcliffe (Mother’s Younger Brother).
March 20, 1997 - Toronto, Canada
Brian Stokes Mitchell, Audra McDonald, Marin Mazzie
November 2, 1997 - Los Angeles
Brian Stokes Mitchell (Coalhouse Walker, Jr.), Marcia Mitzman Gaven (Mother), John Rubenstien (Tateh), LaChanze (Sarah), John Dossett (Father), Scott Carolo (Younger Brother), Judy Kaye (Emma Goldman), Susan Wood (Evelyn Nesbit)
December 31, 1997 - Broadway
Brian Stokes Mitchell (Coalhouse Walker Jr.), Peter Friedman (Tateh), Marin Mazzie (Mother), Audra McDonald (Sarah), Mark Jacoby (Father), Steven Sutcliffe (Mother's Younger Brother), Tommy Hollis (Booker T. Washington), Jim Corti (Harry Houdini), Judy Kaye (Emma Goldman), Lynnette Perry (Evelyn Nesbit), Alex Strange (The Little Boy), Conrad McLaren (Grandfather), Lea Michele (The Little Girl), Mike O'Carroll (J.P. Morgan), Larry Daggett (Henry Ford), Vanessa Townsell-Crisp (Sarah's Friend) and David Mucci (Willie Conklin)
December 20, 1998 - Chicago
James Stovall (Coalhouse Walker, Jr.), Barbara Walsh (Mother), Peter Kevoian (Tateh), Lovena Fox (Sarah), Joseph Delliger (Father), John Frenzer (Younger Brother), Mary Gutzi (Emma Goldman)
January 16, 2000 - Broadway, Final Performance
Donna Bullock (Mother), Joseph Dellger (Father), Alton Fitzgerald White (Coalhouse Walker, Jr.), Darlesia Cearcy (Sarah), Michael Rupert (Tateh), Scott Carollo (Mother's Younger Brother), Michelle Dawson (Evelyn Nesbitt), Bernie Yvon (Harry Houdini), Judy Kaye (Emma Goldman)
April 5, 2003 - London
Kevyn Morrow (Coalhouse Walker Jr.) Maria Friedman (Mother) Dave Willets (Father) Matthew White (Younger Brother) Graham Bickley (Tateh) Emma Jay Thomas (Sarah) Susie McKenna (Emma Goldman) Rebecca Thornhill (Evelyn Nesbitt) David Durham (Booker T. Washington)
June 14, 2003 - London, Final Performance
Kevyn Morrow (Coalhouse Walker Jr.), Maria Friedman (Mother), Dave Willetts (Father), Matthew White (Younger Brother), Graham Bickley (Tateh), Emma Jay Thomas (Sarah), Susie McKenna (Emma Goldman), Rebecca Thornhill (Evelyn Nesbit), David Durham (Booker T. Washington), Samuel James (Harry Houdini), Howard Ellis (Willie Conklin)
July 10, 2005 - Papermill Playhouse
Quentin Earl Darrington (Coalhouse Walker, Jr.), Rachel York (Mother), Neal Benari (Tateh), Kenita R. Miller (Sarah), David Hess (Father), Shonn Wiley (Younger Brother), Debra Cardona (Emma Goldman), Besty Wolfe (Evelyn Nesbit), Justin Lee Miller (Booker T. Washington), Matthew Scott (Harry Houdini), Greg Roderick (Henry Ford), Kelly Rucker (Sarah's Friend)
April 22, 2009 - Kennedy Center
Quentin Earl Darrington (Coalhouse Walker Jr.), Ron Bohmer (Father), Christiane Noll (Mother), Manoel Felciano (Tateh), Jennlee Shallow (Sarah), Bobby Steggert (Younger Brother), Leigh Ann Larkin (Evelyn Nesbit), Jonathan Hammond (Harry Houdini), Donna Migliaccio (Emma Goldman), Christopher Cox (Little Boy), Sarah Rosenthal (Little Girl), Eric Jordan Young (Booker T. Washington)
October 23, 2009 - Broadway Revival, First Preview
Christiane Noll (Mother), Quentin Earl Darrington (Coalhouse Walker Jr.), Robert Petkoff (Tateh), Ron Bohmer (Father), Bobby Steggert (Mother's Younger Brother), Stephanie Umoh (Sarah), Christopher Cox (The Little Boy), Sarah Rosenthal (The Little Girl), Jonathan Hammond (Harry Houdini), Donna Migliaccio (Emma Goldman), Savannah Wise (Evelyn Nesbit), Eric Jordan Young (Booker T. Washington), Mark Aldrich (Willie Conklin), Sumayya Ali (Soprano Soloist), Terence Archie (Matthew Henson), Corey Bradley, Jayden Brockington (Coalhouse Walker III), Jennifer Evans (Kathleen), Aaron Galligan-Stierle (Henry Ford), Carly Hughes, Valisia Lekae, Dan Manning (Grandfather), Michael X. Martin (J.P. Morgan), Mike McGowan (Charles S. Whitman), Tracy Lynn Olivera (Brigit), Bryonha Parham (Sarah's Friend), Mamie Parris, Nicole Powell, Arbender J. Robinson, Benjamin Schrader, Wallace Smith, Josh Walden (Harry K. Thaw), Catherine Walker
December 29, 2009 - Broadway Revival
Ron Bohmer, Quentin Earl Darrington, Christiane Noll, Robert Petkoff, Bobby Steggert, Stephanie Umoh, Christopher Cox, Sarah Rosenthal
Untracked
January 10, 2010 - Broadway Revival, Final Performanc
Quentin Earl Darrington (Coalhouse Walker Jr.), Mamie Parris (u/s Mother), Robert Petkoff (Tateh), Bobby Steggert (Mother’s Younger Brother), Stephanie Umoh (Sarah), Ron Bohmer (Father), Christopher Cox (The Little Boy), Sarah Rosenthal (The Little Girl), Dan Manning (Grandfather), Jonathan Hammond (Harry Houdini), Donna Migliaccio (Emma Goldman), Savannah Wise (Evelyn Nesbit), Eric Jordan Young (Booker T. Washington), Aaron Galligan-Stierle (Henry Ford), Michael X. Martin (J.P. Morgan)
(*juniper47’s master*)
February 18, 2013 - Avery Fisher Hall Concert
Norm Lewis, Howard McGillin, Lea Salonga, Manoel Felciano, Patina Miller, Michael Arden, Kerry Butler, Lewis Grosso, Dick Latessa, Tyne Daly, Jose Llana, Jarrod Emick, Phillip Boykin, Matt Cavenaugh , Michael McCormick, NaTasha Yvette Williams, Lilla Crawford
October 19, 2016 - Charing Cross
Earl Carpenter (Father), Anita Lousie Combe (Mother), Jonathan Stewart (Younger Brother), Anthony Cable (Grandfather), Gary Tushaw (Tateh), Ako Mitchell (Coalhouse Walker Jr.), Jennifer Saayeng (Sarah), Seyi Omooba (Sarah’s Friend), Simon Anthony (Willie Conklin), Joanna Hickman (Evelyn Nesbit), Christopher Dickins (Harry Houdini), Valerie Cutko (Emma Goldman), Tom Giles (Henry Ford), Matt Devereaux (J.P. Morgan), Cavin Cornwall (Booker T. Washinton)
March 9, 2019 - Pasadena Playhouse
Luke Barbato Smith, Shannon Warne, Zachary Ford, Dylan Saunders, Gregory North, Marc Ginsburg, Iara Nemirosky, Clifton Duncan, Bryce Charles, Candace J. Washington, Michael Thomas-Visgar, Katharine McDonough, Benjamin Schrader, Valerie Perri, Ryan Dietz, Tom G. McMahon, Dedrick Bonner, Molly Stilliens, Cornelius Jones Jr., Michael Deni
Susan Egan (Evelyn Nesbit), Victor Garber (Father) Joel Grey (Tateh), Audra McDonald (Sarah), Brian Stokes Mitchell (Coalhouse Walker, Jr.), Donna Murphy (Mother)
December 1996 (Exact Date Unknown) - Second Reading
Brian Stokes Mitchell (Coalhouse Walker, Jr.), Ann Crumb (Mother), Peter Friedman (Tateh), Thursday Farrar (Sarah), Tovah Feldshuh (Emma Goldman), Stephen Bogardus (Father), Steven Sutcliffe (Mother’s Younger Brother).
March 20, 1997 - Toronto, Canada
Brian Stokes Mitchell, Audra McDonald, Marin Mazzie
November 2, 1997 - Los Angeles
Brian Stokes Mitchell (Coalhouse Walker, Jr.), Marcia Mitzman Gaven (Mother), John Rubenstien (Tateh), LaChanze (Sarah), John Dossett (Father), Scott Carolo (Younger Brother), Judy Kaye (Emma Goldman), Susan Wood (Evelyn Nesbit)
December 31, 1997 - Broadway
Brian Stokes Mitchell (Coalhouse Walker Jr.), Peter Friedman (Tateh), Marin Mazzie (Mother), Audra McDonald (Sarah), Mark Jacoby (Father), Steven Sutcliffe (Mother's Younger Brother), Tommy Hollis (Booker T. Washington), Jim Corti (Harry Houdini), Judy Kaye (Emma Goldman), Lynnette Perry (Evelyn Nesbit), Alex Strange (The Little Boy), Conrad McLaren (Grandfather), Lea Michele (The Little Girl), Mike O'Carroll (J.P. Morgan), Larry Daggett (Henry Ford), Vanessa Townsell-Crisp (Sarah's Friend) and David Mucci (Willie Conklin)
December 20, 1998 - Chicago
James Stovall (Coalhouse Walker, Jr.), Barbara Walsh (Mother), Peter Kevoian (Tateh), Lovena Fox (Sarah), Joseph Delliger (Father), John Frenzer (Younger Brother), Mary Gutzi (Emma Goldman)
January 16, 2000 - Broadway, Final Performance
Donna Bullock (Mother), Joseph Dellger (Father), Alton Fitzgerald White (Coalhouse Walker, Jr.), Darlesia Cearcy (Sarah), Michael Rupert (Tateh), Scott Carollo (Mother's Younger Brother), Michelle Dawson (Evelyn Nesbitt), Bernie Yvon (Harry Houdini), Judy Kaye (Emma Goldman)
April 5, 2003 - London
Kevyn Morrow (Coalhouse Walker Jr.) Maria Friedman (Mother) Dave Willets (Father) Matthew White (Younger Brother) Graham Bickley (Tateh) Emma Jay Thomas (Sarah) Susie McKenna (Emma Goldman) Rebecca Thornhill (Evelyn Nesbitt) David Durham (Booker T. Washington)
June 14, 2003 - London, Final Performance
Kevyn Morrow (Coalhouse Walker Jr.), Maria Friedman (Mother), Dave Willetts (Father), Matthew White (Younger Brother), Graham Bickley (Tateh), Emma Jay Thomas (Sarah), Susie McKenna (Emma Goldman), Rebecca Thornhill (Evelyn Nesbit), David Durham (Booker T. Washington), Samuel James (Harry Houdini), Howard Ellis (Willie Conklin)
July 10, 2005 - Papermill Playhouse
Quentin Earl Darrington (Coalhouse Walker, Jr.), Rachel York (Mother), Neal Benari (Tateh), Kenita R. Miller (Sarah), David Hess (Father), Shonn Wiley (Younger Brother), Debra Cardona (Emma Goldman), Besty Wolfe (Evelyn Nesbit), Justin Lee Miller (Booker T. Washington), Matthew Scott (Harry Houdini), Greg Roderick (Henry Ford), Kelly Rucker (Sarah's Friend)
April 22, 2009 - Kennedy Center
Quentin Earl Darrington (Coalhouse Walker Jr.), Ron Bohmer (Father), Christiane Noll (Mother), Manoel Felciano (Tateh), Jennlee Shallow (Sarah), Bobby Steggert (Younger Brother), Leigh Ann Larkin (Evelyn Nesbit), Jonathan Hammond (Harry Houdini), Donna Migliaccio (Emma Goldman), Christopher Cox (Little Boy), Sarah Rosenthal (Little Girl), Eric Jordan Young (Booker T. Washington)
October 23, 2009 - Broadway Revival, First Preview
Christiane Noll (Mother), Quentin Earl Darrington (Coalhouse Walker Jr.), Robert Petkoff (Tateh), Ron Bohmer (Father), Bobby Steggert (Mother's Younger Brother), Stephanie Umoh (Sarah), Christopher Cox (The Little Boy), Sarah Rosenthal (The Little Girl), Jonathan Hammond (Harry Houdini), Donna Migliaccio (Emma Goldman), Savannah Wise (Evelyn Nesbit), Eric Jordan Young (Booker T. Washington), Mark Aldrich (Willie Conklin), Sumayya Ali (Soprano Soloist), Terence Archie (Matthew Henson), Corey Bradley, Jayden Brockington (Coalhouse Walker III), Jennifer Evans (Kathleen), Aaron Galligan-Stierle (Henry Ford), Carly Hughes, Valisia Lekae, Dan Manning (Grandfather), Michael X. Martin (J.P. Morgan), Mike McGowan (Charles S. Whitman), Tracy Lynn Olivera (Brigit), Bryonha Parham (Sarah's Friend), Mamie Parris, Nicole Powell, Arbender J. Robinson, Benjamin Schrader, Wallace Smith, Josh Walden (Harry K. Thaw), Catherine Walker
December 29, 2009 - Broadway Revival
Ron Bohmer, Quentin Earl Darrington, Christiane Noll, Robert Petkoff, Bobby Steggert, Stephanie Umoh, Christopher Cox, Sarah Rosenthal
Untracked
January 10, 2010 - Broadway Revival, Final Performanc
Quentin Earl Darrington (Coalhouse Walker Jr.), Mamie Parris (u/s Mother), Robert Petkoff (Tateh), Bobby Steggert (Mother’s Younger Brother), Stephanie Umoh (Sarah), Ron Bohmer (Father), Christopher Cox (The Little Boy), Sarah Rosenthal (The Little Girl), Dan Manning (Grandfather), Jonathan Hammond (Harry Houdini), Donna Migliaccio (Emma Goldman), Savannah Wise (Evelyn Nesbit), Eric Jordan Young (Booker T. Washington), Aaron Galligan-Stierle (Henry Ford), Michael X. Martin (J.P. Morgan)
(*juniper47’s master*)
February 18, 2013 - Avery Fisher Hall Concert
Norm Lewis, Howard McGillin, Lea Salonga, Manoel Felciano, Patina Miller, Michael Arden, Kerry Butler, Lewis Grosso, Dick Latessa, Tyne Daly, Jose Llana, Jarrod Emick, Phillip Boykin, Matt Cavenaugh , Michael McCormick, NaTasha Yvette Williams, Lilla Crawford
October 19, 2016 - Charing Cross
Earl Carpenter (Father), Anita Lousie Combe (Mother), Jonathan Stewart (Younger Brother), Anthony Cable (Grandfather), Gary Tushaw (Tateh), Ako Mitchell (Coalhouse Walker Jr.), Jennifer Saayeng (Sarah), Seyi Omooba (Sarah’s Friend), Simon Anthony (Willie Conklin), Joanna Hickman (Evelyn Nesbit), Christopher Dickins (Harry Houdini), Valerie Cutko (Emma Goldman), Tom Giles (Henry Ford), Matt Devereaux (J.P. Morgan), Cavin Cornwall (Booker T. Washinton)
March 9, 2019 - Pasadena Playhouse
Luke Barbato Smith, Shannon Warne, Zachary Ford, Dylan Saunders, Gregory North, Marc Ginsburg, Iara Nemirosky, Clifton Duncan, Bryce Charles, Candace J. Washington, Michael Thomas-Visgar, Katharine McDonough, Benjamin Schrader, Valerie Perri, Ryan Dietz, Tom G. McMahon, Dedrick Bonner, Molly Stilliens, Cornelius Jones Jr., Michael Deni