2000 (Date Unknown) - Los Angeles
John Torres, John Griffin, Jenna Leigh Green, Keili Lefkovitz, Wallace Smith, Mark Edgar Stephens, Stephanie Andersen, Philip Lightstone
March 27, 2004 - Off-Broadway
Michael Arden (Peter), John Hill (Jason), Jenna Leigh Green (Ivy), Aaron Lohr (Matt), Natalie Joy Johnson (Nadia), Kaitlin Nopkins (Claire), Jim Price (Priest), Romelda T. Benjamin (Sr. Chantelle), Adam Fleming (Lucas), Sasha Allen (Tanya/Angel), Kearran Giovanni (Kyra/Angel), Kay Trinidad (Diane), Lindsay Scott (Rory), Michael Cannon (Zach), Isaac Calpito (Alan), Scott Allaguaer (swing)
April 17, 2004 - Off-Broadway
Michael Arden (Peter), John Hill (Jason), Jenna Leigh Green (Ivy), Aaron Lohr (Matt), Natalie Joy Johnson (Nadia), Kaitlin Nopkins (Claire), Jim Price (Priest), Romelda T. Benjamin (Sr. Chantelle), Adam Fleming (Lucas), Sasha Allen (Tanya/Angel), Kearran Giovanni (Kyra/Angel), Kay Trinidad (Diane), Lindsay Scott (Rory), Michael Cannon (Zach), Isaac Calpito (Alan), Scott Allaguaer (swing)
May 2, 2004 - Off-Broadway
Michael Arden (Peter), John Hill (Jason), Jenna Leigh Green (Ivy), Aaron Lohr (Matt), Natalie Joy Johnson (Nadia), Kaitlin Nopkins (Claire), Jim Price (Priest), Romelda T. Benjamin (Sr. Chantelle), Adam Fleming (Lucas), Sasha Allen (Tanya/Angel), Kearran Giovanni (Kyra/Angel), Kay Trinidad (Diane), Lindsay Scott (Rory), Michael Cannon (Zach), Isaac Calpito (Alan), Scott Allaguaer (Swing)
May 10, 2004 - Off-Broadway
Michael Arden (Peter), John Hill (Jason), Jenna Leigh Green (Ivy), Natalie Joy Johnson (Natalie), Aaron Lohr (Matt), Kaitlin Hopkins (Claire), Jim Price (Priest), Romelda T. Benjamin (Sister Chantelle), Adam Fleming (Lucas), Sasha Allen (Tanya), Kearran Giovanni (Kyra), Isaac Calpito (Alan), Kay Trinidad (Diane), Lindsay Scott (Rory), Mike Cannon (Zach)
January 26, 2013 - New World Stages
Jason Hite (Jason), Taylor Trensch (Peter), Elizabeth Judd (Ivy), Barrett Wilbert Weed (Nadia), Gerard Canonico (Matt), Alice Lee (Diane), Sara Kapner (Madison), Ariana Groover (Vanessa), Alex Wyse (Alan), Justin Gregory Lopez (Beto), Michael Tacconi (Nick), Casey Garvin (Zack), Missi Pyle (Sister Joan), Jerold E. Solomon (Father Mike)
Untracked
John Torres, John Griffin, Jenna Leigh Green, Keili Lefkovitz, Wallace Smith, Mark Edgar Stephens, Stephanie Andersen, Philip Lightstone
March 27, 2004 - Off-Broadway
Michael Arden (Peter), John Hill (Jason), Jenna Leigh Green (Ivy), Aaron Lohr (Matt), Natalie Joy Johnson (Nadia), Kaitlin Nopkins (Claire), Jim Price (Priest), Romelda T. Benjamin (Sr. Chantelle), Adam Fleming (Lucas), Sasha Allen (Tanya/Angel), Kearran Giovanni (Kyra/Angel), Kay Trinidad (Diane), Lindsay Scott (Rory), Michael Cannon (Zach), Isaac Calpito (Alan), Scott Allaguaer (swing)
April 17, 2004 - Off-Broadway
Michael Arden (Peter), John Hill (Jason), Jenna Leigh Green (Ivy), Aaron Lohr (Matt), Natalie Joy Johnson (Nadia), Kaitlin Nopkins (Claire), Jim Price (Priest), Romelda T. Benjamin (Sr. Chantelle), Adam Fleming (Lucas), Sasha Allen (Tanya/Angel), Kearran Giovanni (Kyra/Angel), Kay Trinidad (Diane), Lindsay Scott (Rory), Michael Cannon (Zach), Isaac Calpito (Alan), Scott Allaguaer (swing)
May 2, 2004 - Off-Broadway
Michael Arden (Peter), John Hill (Jason), Jenna Leigh Green (Ivy), Aaron Lohr (Matt), Natalie Joy Johnson (Nadia), Kaitlin Nopkins (Claire), Jim Price (Priest), Romelda T. Benjamin (Sr. Chantelle), Adam Fleming (Lucas), Sasha Allen (Tanya/Angel), Kearran Giovanni (Kyra/Angel), Kay Trinidad (Diane), Lindsay Scott (Rory), Michael Cannon (Zach), Isaac Calpito (Alan), Scott Allaguaer (Swing)
May 10, 2004 - Off-Broadway
Michael Arden (Peter), John Hill (Jason), Jenna Leigh Green (Ivy), Natalie Joy Johnson (Natalie), Aaron Lohr (Matt), Kaitlin Hopkins (Claire), Jim Price (Priest), Romelda T. Benjamin (Sister Chantelle), Adam Fleming (Lucas), Sasha Allen (Tanya), Kearran Giovanni (Kyra), Isaac Calpito (Alan), Kay Trinidad (Diane), Lindsay Scott (Rory), Mike Cannon (Zach)
January 26, 2013 - New World Stages
Jason Hite (Jason), Taylor Trensch (Peter), Elizabeth Judd (Ivy), Barrett Wilbert Weed (Nadia), Gerard Canonico (Matt), Alice Lee (Diane), Sara Kapner (Madison), Ariana Groover (Vanessa), Alex Wyse (Alan), Justin Gregory Lopez (Beto), Michael Tacconi (Nick), Casey Garvin (Zack), Missi Pyle (Sister Joan), Jerold E. Solomon (Father Mike)
Untracked